Dog owners can tell if their discipline methods are working by observing their dog’s behavior over time. Here are some signs that your discipline methods are effective:

1. Consistency in behavior: If your dog is consistently exhibiting the desired behavior, it is a good sign that your discipline methods are working. For example, if you have been working on teaching your dog to sit and stay, and they consistently respond to the command, it is a sign that your training methods are effective.
2. Reduced frequency of bad behavior: If your dog is exhibiting bad behavior less frequently, it is a sign that your discipline methods are working. For example, if your dog used to jump on guests every time they entered the house, but now only jumps occasionally, it is a sign that your training methods are having an impact.
3. Willingness to learn: If your dog is enthusiastic and willing to learn during training sessions, it is a sign that your discipline methods are effective. Dogs that are engaged and motivated during training sessions are more likely to learn and retain the desired behavior.
4. Positive demeanor: If your dog is happy and relaxed during training sessions and in everyday life, it is a sign that your discipline methods are working. Dogs that are stressed, anxious, or fearful are less likely to learn and may exhibit more bad behavior.
5. Good relationship with owner: If your dog has a good relationship with you and is eager to spend time with you, it is a sign that your discipline methods are effective. Dogs that feel loved and respected are more likely to respond positively to training and exhibit good behavior.

In conclusion, dog owners can tell if their discipline methods are working by observing their dog’s behavior over time. Signs that your discipline methods are effective include consistency in behavior, reduced frequency of bad behavior, willingness to learn, positive demeanor, and a good relationship with the owner. It is important to remember that discipline methods should always be humane and avoid punishment, and should focus on positive reinforcement and redirection of attention.